Yesterday at the Park Avenue Armory, alongside "the Art Show", the Art Dealers Association of America [ADAA] and The Art Newspaper presented a panel on "Transparency in the market: can we have more of it..."
The panel included art dealers, an art consultant, an art lawyer, the chairman of Christie's International, and the founder of The Art Newspaper. The title presented a double meaning for these panelists to deconstruct. Should we have more transparency? Is it possible to have more transparency? The tension between these two questions underpinned the entire discussion, which unfolded in three segments.
First, the panelists discussed third-party guarantees at auction. The rules on this practice are different at each auction house. At the summit, no sense of agreement was reached as to how much information regarding minimum sale prices and third party guarantees should be revealed at auction.
Second, they discussed the recent English High Court decision regarding a sale of a Leonardo Da Vinci involving multiple dealers. There is no specific legislation in place regarding these practices of dealers, and matters are often left to the common law of contract, misrepresentation in particular. Although many people in the art world "pride themselves on handshakes," all of the panelists agreed that precise documentation and clear contracts are needed when a sale reaches a certain amount.