Phone bidding at auctions is nothing new (the image on the left dates back to a 2006 sale); however, the practice has grown in recent years.[1] For many buyers and collectors phone bidding is more convenient, it allows for anonymity, and some choose it because they do not want their governments knowing how much money they are spending.[2] Regardless of the reasons, the popularity of over the phone bidding is evidenced by the amount of business several well-known auction houses have recently done using this method.[3]
However, phone bidding creates many problems both logistical and legal. Logistically, phone bidding usually requires that the auction house have multiple landlines available during the sale.[4] As for the buyer using a cell-phone, he or she needs to remain in an area where there is a strong signal and have an additional line available in case the call gets dropped. If a call does disconnect, the one bidding on the buyer’s behalf must quickly call back and inform the buyer of what is happening at the auction simultaneously as events occur.
Legally, over the phone bidding implicates enforceable fiduciary duties. Fiduciary duties are owed as between the one bidding on the buyer’s behalf (agent) and the buyer (principal). These are not specific statutorily enumerated duties but require that the agent act in the principal’s best interest.[5] Depending on the circumstances, this would likely require the agent to inform the buyer of any bids placed, place bids when the buyer authorizes the agent to do so, not place bids the agent is not authorized to, and any other duties a court may determine proper in that circumstance.
A prime example of the legal problems arising from over-the-phone bidding is the 2009 case involving a dispute between art collector Gregory Callimanopulos and Christie’s over the sale of a Sam Francis painting titled Grey.[6] In Callimanopulos v. Christie’s Inc., 621 F. Supp. 2d 127 (S.D.N.Y. 2009), plaintiff bid on a lot over the phone via his agent April Richon Jacobs, Christie’s Co-Head of Evening Sale. He made a bid for $3 million, and the auctioneer Christopher Burge declared the Francis painting was sold to him as the hammer dropped. The dispute arose because seconds later the bidding was reopened and Grey ultimately sold to another bidder, Joanne Heyler, Director and Chief Curator of the Broad Art Foundation for $3.2 million. Callimanopulos sued to enjoin Christie’s from conveying the painting to Heyler but his request for injunctive relief was denied. The court found that at the time of the sale, Burge did not notice Heyler’s bid, which occurred just before the fall of the hammer. The oversight was pointed out by other Christie’s employees and at Burge’s discretion, bidding resumed.[7]