By Kouros Sadeghi-Nejad
On May 15, 2023, in a landmark decision for Italy’s cultural heritage property protection, Florence’s Gallerie dell'Accademia prevailed in its legal battle to secure its image rights to Michelangelo’s iconic David sculpture.[1] The Gallerie initiated the lawsuit against the publishing house Edizioni Conde Nast, who appropriated the 16th-century sculpture’s likeness three years prior for the cover of GQ Italia in an “openly advertising key” and without acquiring a permit from the museum.[2], [3] The lawsuit raised questions over the ability of museums to legally claim image rights on artworks belonging to the public domain and whether commercial use of such images may undermine the preservation of collective identity through cultural heritage.
The image under scrutiny utilized a 'lenticular cartotecnica' mechanism to superimpose an image of the model Pietro Boselli onto that of David. This mechanism creates an illusion where, based on the viewer's perspective, the image can seem to shift or morph from one to the other, thereby enabling both images to coexist in the same physical face.