• About
    • Mission
    • Team
    • Boards
    • Mentions & Testimonials
    • Institutional Recognition
    • Annual Reports
    • Current & Past Sponsors
    • Contact Us
  • Resources
    • Article Collection
    • Podcast: Art in Brief
    • AML and the Art Market
    • AI and Art Authentication
    • Newsletter
      • Subscribe
      • Archives
      • In Brief
    • Art Law Library
    • Movies
    • Nazi-looted Art Restitution Database
    • Global Network
      • Courses and Programs
      • Artists’ Assistance
      • Bar Associations
      • Legal Sources
      • Law Firms
      • Student Societies
      • Research Institutions
    • Additional resources
      • The “Interview” Project
  • Events
    • Worldwide Calendar
    • Our Events
      • All Events
      • Annual Conferences
        • 2025 Art Law Conference
        • 2024 Art Law Conference
        • 2023 Art Law Conference
        • 2022 Art Law Conference
        • 2015 Art Law Conference
  • Programs
    • Visual Artists’ Legal Clinics
      • Art & Copyright Law Clinic
      • Artist-Dealer Relationships Clinic
      • Artist Legacy and Estate Planning Clinic
      • Visual Artists’ Immigration Clinic
    • Summer School
      • 2026
      • 2025
    • Internship and Fellowship
    • Judith Bresler Fellowship
  • Case Law Database
  • Log in
  • Become a Member
  • Donate
  • Log in
  • Become a Member
  • Donate
Center for Art Law
  • About
    About
    • Mission
    • Team
    • Boards
    • Mentions & Testimonials
    • Institutional Recognition
    • Annual Reports
    • Current & Past Sponsors
    • Contact Us
  • Resources
    Resources
    • Article Collection
    • Podcast: Art in Brief
    • AML and the Art Market
    • AI and Art Authentication
    • Newsletter
      Newsletter
      • Subscribe
      • Archives
      • In Brief
    • Art Law Library
    • Movies
    • Nazi-looted Art Restitution Database
    • Global Network
      Global Network
      • Courses and Programs
      • Artists’ Assistance
      • Bar Associations
      • Legal Sources
      • Law Firms
      • Student Societies
      • Research Institutions
    • Additional resources
      Additional resources
      • The “Interview” Project
  • Events
    Events
    • Worldwide Calendar
    • Our Events
      Our Events
      • All Events
      • Annual Conferences
        Annual Conferences
        • 2025 Art Law Conference
        • 2024 Art Law Conference
        • 2023 Art Law Conference
        • 2022 Art Law Conference
        • 2015 Art Law Conference
  • Programs
    Programs
    • Visual Artists’ Legal Clinics
      Visual Artists’ Legal Clinics
      • Art & Copyright Law Clinic
      • Artist-Dealer Relationships Clinic
      • Artist Legacy and Estate Planning Clinic
      • Visual Artists’ Immigration Clinic
    • Summer School
      Summer School
      • 2026
      • 2025
    • Internship and Fellowship
    • Judith Bresler Fellowship
  • Case Law Database
Home image/svg+xml 2021 Timothée Giet Event image/svg+xml 2021 Timothée Giet Recent Global Developments in Nazi-Looted Art Restitution
Back

Recent Global Developments in Nazi-Looted Art Restitution

December 15, 2025

Center for Art Law Recent Global Developments in Nazi Looted Art Restitution

About this Event:

Learn about the latest developments to the HEAR Act, the reform in the German Commission & use of digital tools in restitution efforts!

Want to stay informed about the latest developments in the restitution of Nazi-looted art? Curious about what’s happening in the U.S. and Germany, or how new technologies are shaping research in this field?

“Recent Global Developments in Nazi-Looted Art Restitution” featured a panel of professionals from diverse backgrounds, discussing key updates in the restitution of Nazi-looted art, including the current Senate vote on the HEAR Act and its implications for restitution claims in the U.S., the recent modification from the German Commission to Arbitral Court in Germany, and the use of digital tools and data to advance restitution research and claims.

Speakers:

Amanda Buonaiuto

Amanda BUONAIUTO is a Brazilian lawyer with a specialization in Nazi-looted art restitution. With expertise in provenance research, she is responsible for leading the Nazi-Looted Art Restitution Project for the Center for Art Law.

Peter Toren

Peter J. TOREN is an intellectual property attorney and a member of the Center for Art Law Board of Directors. He represents his family in a case against the Federal Republic of Germany involving family art stolen during the Second World War (Toren v. Federal Republic of Germany, 1:16-cv-01885-RJL (D.D.C.)).

Olaf S. Ossman

Olaf S. OSSMANN is a Swiss & German attorney who is a member at the “Studies of Jewish Law at the Humboldt University Berlin” and Member of the Board of Governors of the International Association of Jewish Lawyers (IJL). He has been a lecturer and advisor of the Rabbinerseminar Berlin as well the working group “Legal issues of looted art” at the “Holocaust Era Asset Conference, Prag”. Mr. Ossmann is the Founding President of the “Stiftung Menschenbild, Winterthur” and serves as a Board Member of the “Eva Cassirer Stiftung, Vaduz.”

Laurel Zuckerman

Laurel ZUCKERMAN’s work currently focuses on the art world and the Holocaust. She explores how linked open data, natural language processing, network analysis and the digital tools and techniques of investigative data journalism can be used to identify patterns in false provenances in Nazi-looted art and duress sales. In 2016, after twelve years of research, she filed a lawsuit against the Metropolitan Museum of Art for the restitution of Picasso’s The Actor (Zuckerman v. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, No. 18-634 (2d Cir. 2019)).

Lilah Aubrey

Lilah AUBREY is Managing Director of Art Ashes (Art Restitution To Assist Survivors of the Holocaust Emergency Services), a 501(c)(3) nonprofit dedicated to helping families recover Nazi-looted art. Founded in 2023, Art Ashes enhances restitution efforts by providing resources and funding to claimants, as well as directly supporting independent researchers involved at various stages of recovery. The foundation also promotes education around the theft of Jewish property and ethical research practices. When restitutions result in the sale of artwork, families agree to donate a portion of proceeds to Holocaust Survivors in financial need—who still comprise nearly half of the remaining Survivor population. In addition to her work with Art Ashes, Lilah is an independent advisor and art collection manager, following roles at Richard Gray Gallery in New York and Chicago and at Sotheby’s in Boston. Specializing in 20th- and 21st-century art, she oversees consignments, sales, loans, appraisals, and estate management. Drawing on experience across the art market, she works closely with galleries, auction houses, and both private and institutional clients to shape collections, guide stewardship, and support cultural philanthropy.

Post navigation

Previous Art and Copyright Law Clinic
Next ‘No-Strike’: Protection of Cultural Heritage against War Crimes in Syria

Related Art Law Articles

Center for Art Law AML Laundry Machines Ad
Art law

Regulation Without Legislation: Combatting Money Laundering in the U.S. Art Market

February 21, 2026
Center for Art Law Susan (Central Park) Legacy Over Licensing Josie Goettel
Art lawcopyrightlicensing

Legacy Over Licensing: How Artist Estates and Museums Are Redefining Control in the Digital Age

February 19, 2026
Center for Art Law M HKA
Art lawLegal Issues in Museum Administration

Flemish Government’s Plan to Dismantle M HKA’s Collection in the Name of Centralization of Art

February 18, 2026
Center for Art Law
Center for Art Law

Follow us on Instagram for the latest in Art Law!

Grab an Early Bird Discount for our new CLE progra Grab an Early Bird Discount for our new CLE program to train lawyers to assist visual artists and dealers in the unique aspects of their relationship.

Center for Art Law’s Art Lawyering Bootcamp: Artist-Dealer Relationships is an in-person, full-day training aimed at preparing lawyers for working with visual artists and dealers, in the unique aspects of their relationship. The bootcamp will be led by veteran attorneys specializing in art law.

This Bootcamp provides participants -- attorneys, law students, law graduates and legal professionals -- with foundational legal knowledge related to the main contracts and regulations governing dealers' and artists' businesses. Through a combination of instructional presentations and mock consultations, participants will gain a solid foundation in the specificities of the law as applied to the visual arts.

Bootcamp participants will be provided with training materials, including presentation slides and an Art Lawyering Bootcamp handbook with additional reading resources.

The event will take place at DLA Piper, 1251 6th Avenue, New York, NY. 9am -5pm.

Art Lawyering Bootcamp participants with CLE tickets will receive New York CLE credits upon successful completion of the training modules. CLE credits pending board approval. 

🎟️ Grab tickets using the link in our bio! 

#centerforartlaw #artlaw #legal #research #lawyer #artlawyer #bootcamp #artistdealer #CLE #trainingprogram
A recent report by the World Jewish Restitution Or A recent report by the World Jewish Restitution Organization (WRJO) states that most American museums provide inadequate provenance information for potentially Nazi-looted objects held in their collections. This is an ongoing problem, as emphasized by the closure of the Nazi-Era Provenance Internet Portal last year. Established in 2003, the portal was intended to act as a public registry of potentially looted art held in museum collections across the United States. However, over its 21-year lifespan, the portal's practitioners struggled to secure ongoing funding and it ultimately became outdated. 

The WJRO report highlights this failure, noting that museums themselves have done little to make provenance information easily accessible. This lack of transparency is a serious blow to the efforts of Holocaust survivors and their descendants to secure the repatriation of seized artworks. WJRO President Gideon Taylor urged American museums to make more tangible efforts to cooperate with Holocaust survivors and their families in their pursuit of justice.

🔗 Click the link in our bio to read more.

#centerforartlaw #artlaw #museumissues #nazilootedart #wwii #artlawyer #legalresearch
Join us for the Second Edition of Center for Art L Join us for the Second Edition of Center for Art Law Summer School! An immersive five-day educational program designed for individuals interested in the dynamic and ever-evolving field of art law. 

Taking place in the vibrant art hub of New York City, the program will provide participants with a foundational understanding of art law, opportunities to explore key issues in the field, and access to a network of professionals and peers with shared interests. Participants will also have the opportunity to see how things work from a hands-on and practical perspective by visiting galleries, artist studios, auction houses and law firms, and speak with professionals dedicated to and passionate about the field. 

Applications are open now through March 1st!

🎟️ APPLY NOW using the link in our bio! 

#centerforartlaw #artlawsummerschool #newyork #artlaw #artlawyer #legal #lawyer #art
Join us for an informative presentation and pro bo Join us for an informative presentation and pro bono consultations to better understand the current art and copyright law landscape. Copyright law is a body of federal law that grants authors exclusive rights over their original works — from paintings and photographs to sculptures, as well as other fixed and tangible creative forms. Once protection attaches, copyright owners have exclusive economic rights that allow them to control how their work is reproduced, modified and distributed, among other uses.

Albeit theoretically simple, in practice copyright law is complex and nuanced: what works acquire such protection? How can creatives better protect their assets or, if they wish, exploit them for their monetary benefit? 

🎟️ Grab tickets using the link in our bio! 

#centerforartlaw #artlaw #legal #research #lawyer #artlawyer #bootcamp #copyright #CLE #trainingprogram
In October, the Hispanic Society Museum and Librar In October, the Hispanic Society Museum and Library deaccessioned forty five paintings from its collection through an auction at Christie's. The sale included primarily Old-Master paintings of religious and aristocratic subjects. Notable works in the sale included a painting from the workshop of El Greco, a copy of a work by Titian, as well as a portrait of Isabella of Portugal, and Clemente Del Camino y Parladé’s “El Columpio (The Swing). 

The purpose of the sale was to raise funds to further diversify the museum's collection. In a statement, the institution stated that the works selected for sale are not in line with their core mission as they seek to expand and diversify their collection.

🔗 Click the link in our bio to read more.

#centerforartlaw #artlawnews #artlawresearch #legalresearch #artlawyer #art #lawyer
Check out our new episode where Paris and Andrea s Check out our new episode where Paris and Andrea speak with Ali Nour, who recounts his journey from Khartoum to Cairo amid the ongoing civil war, and describes how he became involved with the Emergency Response Committee - a group of Sudanese heritage officials working to safeguard Sudan’s cultural heritage. 

🎙️ Click the link in our bio to listen anywhere you get your podcasts! 

#centerforartlaw #artlaw #artlawyer #legal #research #podcast #february #legalresearch #newepisode #culturalheritage #sudaneseheritage
When you see ‘February’ what comes to mind? Birthd When you see ‘February’ what comes to mind? Birthdays of friends? Olympic games? Anniversary of war? Democracy dying in darkness? Days getting longer? We could have chosen a better image for the February cover but somehow the 1913 work of Umberto Boccioni (an artist who died during World War 1) “Dynamism of a Soccer Player” seemed to hit the right note. Let’s keep going, individuals and team players.

Center for Art Law is pressing on with events and research. We have over 200 applications to review for the Summer Internship Program, meetings, obligations. Reach out if you have questions or suggestions. We cannot wait to introduce to you our Spring Interns and we encourage you to share and keep channels of communication open. 

📚 Read more using the link in our bio! Make sure to subscribe so you don't miss any upcoming newsletters!

#centerforartlaw #artlaw #artlawyer #legal #research #newsletter #february #legalresearch
Join the Center for Art Law for conversation with Join the Center for Art Law for conversation with Frank Born and Caryn Keppler on legacy and estate planning!

When planning for the preservation of their professional legacies and the future custodianship of their oeuvres’, artists are faced with unique concerns and challenges. Frank Born, artist and art dealer, and Caryn Keppler, tax and estate attorney, will share their perspectives on legacy and estate planning. Discussion will focus on which documents to gather, and which professionals to get in touch with throughout the process of legacy planning.

This event is affiliated with the Artist Legacy and Estate Planning Clinic which seeks to connect artists, estate administrators, attorneys, tax advisors, and other experts to create meaningful and lasting solutions for expanding the art canon and art legacy planning. 

🎟️ Grab tickets using the link in our bio! 

#centerforartlaw #artlaw #clinic #artlawyer #estateplanning #artistlegacy #legal #research #lawclinic
Authentication is an inherently uncertain practice Authentication is an inherently uncertain practice, one that the art market must depend upon. Although, auction houses don't have to guarantee  authenticity, they have legal duties related to contract law, tort law, and industry customs. The impact of the Old Master cases, sparked change in the industry including Sotheby's acquisition of Orion Analytical. 

📚 To read more about the liabilities of auction houses and the change in forensic tools, read Vivianne Diaz's published article using the link in our bio!
Join us for an informative guest lecture and pro b Join us for an informative guest lecture and pro bono consultations on legacy and estate planning for visual artists.

Calling all visual artists: join the Center for Art Law's Artist Legacy and Estate Planning Clinic for an evening of low-cost consultations with attorneys, tax experts, and other arts professionals with experience in estate and legacy planning.

After a short lecture on a legacy and estate planning topic, attendees with consultation tickets artist will be paired with one of the Center's volunteer professionals (attorneys, appraisers and financial advisors) for a confidential 20-minute consultation. Limited slots are available for the consultation sessions.

Please be sure to read the entire event description using the LinkedIn event below.

🎟️ Grab tickets using the link in our bio!
On May 24, 2024 the UK enacted the Digital Markets On May 24, 2024 the UK enacted the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 (DMCC). This law increases transparency requirements and consumer rights, including reforming subscription contracts. It grants consumers cancellation periods during cooling-off times. 

Charitable organizations, including museums and other cultural institutions, have concerns regarding consumer abuse of this option. 

🔗 Read more about this new law and it's implications in Lauren Stein's published article, including a discussion on how other jurisdictions have approached the issue, using the link in our bio!
Don't miss our on our upcoming Bootcamp on Februar Don't miss our on our upcoming Bootcamp on February 4th! Check out the full event description below:

Join the Center for Art Law for an in-person, full-day training aimed at preparing lawyers for working with art market participants and understanding their unique copyright law needs. The bootcamp will be led by veteran art law attorneys, Louise Carron, Barry Werbin, Carol J. Steinberg, Esq., Scott Sholder, Marc Misthal, specialists in copyright law.

This Bootcamp provides participants -- attorneys, law students, law graduates and legal professionals -- with foundational legal knowledge related to copyright law for art market clients. Through a combination of instructional presentations and mock consultations, participants will gain a solid foundation in copyright law and its specificities as applied to works of visual arts, such as the fair use doctrine and the use of generative artificial intelligence tools.

🎟️ Grab tickets using the link in our bio!
  • About the Center
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter
  • Upcoming Events
  • Internship
  • Case Law Database
  • Log in
  • Become a Member
  • Donate
DISCLAIMER

Center for Art Law is a New York State non-profit fully qualified under provision 501(c)(3)
of the Internal Revenue Code.

The Center does not provide legal representation. Information available on this website is
purely for educational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice.

TERMS OF USE AND PRIVACY POLICY

Your use of the Site (as defined below) constitutes your consent to this Agreement. Please
read our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy carefully.

© 2026 Center for Art Law