Reading Between the Spirals: The Shameless State of the (Art) World
November 18, 2026
By Irina Tarsis
Her face seems to be saying: Here we go again. Tired of being manhandled or man-coveted? Maybe she’s had it with all the disappointments around her. Is she losing patience or sleep, worried over her fate? Has she been doomscrolling and is now undone? She looks ravishing (or ravished). She looks warm (hot). It must be Nice where she is. She looks familiar (Matisse, right? Where has she been recently?). She looks expensive. Is it me, or does she look exhausted, or rather disgusted?
The art market is certainly a spectacular spectator sport, and so is war: protected from the dust, grit and blood, we, the spectators, can sit back and watch whatever is on show. This fall, as always, auction houses are pulling out all the stops for their major evening sales. Nobody wants any trouble, just some drama and record-setting numbers. Artnet is partnering with Kalshi to supply data to predict results of the upcoming auctions. Let’s watch and see. Who is partnering with whom to make a killing? Shall we make predictions on how many people will not live through the winter, or through the night? Which bridges will hold up, and for how long?
On November 17, 2026, Christie’s New York held its 20th Century Evening Sale, and the works that were consigned were important, beautiful, and expensive, as expected. One of the paintings offered this season was a particularly interesting specimen to watch: a Matisse odalisque from 1922, or is it 1921, titled Nu au châle vert/Nu couché, bras gauche replié (the Nude, Nu, the work, she), estimate: $18–25 million (unlike others we will skimp on zeros here).
Sold at the low estimate, the buyer’s premium would have been about $3.4 million; the seller’s financial obligations to the auction house were unknown, ranging from nothing to some percentage of the hammer price. Typically, we, the spectators, are not privy to the specifics of individual contracts and arrangements, nor do we know outright who the individuals behind the scenes are: the clients, the ultimate beneficiaries, the consignors, the prospective bidders, the handlers. Here, we were told that the artwork came from a “Distinguished American Collection,” just like when ordering “The Best Coffee (or Pizza) in the World,” caveat emptor.
While she was on preview at 20 Rockefeller Plaza, this work of art had also been popping up in other places and contexts lately: art once owned by a sanctioned person, per Sanctions.Art database, 2022 in Paris, 2025 Blondel and Ivanoff’s catalogue (if not raisonné then de l’oeuvre), Acquavella Galleries 2026 exhibition, and 2026 cameo in the first season of The Oligarch and the Art Dealer (Andreas Dalsgaard / Denmark, France, Netherlands, Switzerland & United States / 2026). Tantalizing.
Names of specialists and consignors are in penumbra, and names of would-be buyers may or may not be knowable. Christie’s, being Christie’s, will have done its due diligence on the artwork, on the consignment side and the purchasing side in due time and weighed the risks against benefits. The well-oiled machine is that for a reason. To avoid making costly mistakes, it learns from the precedent, and while humans err, in an ideal world, they err less and less. Exceptions prove the rules, and blue chips rule the narrative. It’s just too bad that the numbers that make the news are not only those related to expensive works of art but also explosions and the unbelievable toll human ego and avarice take on their fellow humans.
Lot No. 33A: Numbers Game

Let’s start with the November 2026 auction. According to the auction catalogue, Henri Matisse painted this version of “Nu au châle vert/Nu couché, bras gauche replié” in 1921, in Nice, France. Why 1921? Does it matter? The Côte d’Azur became home to Matisse and his studio after 1917, and a reclining nude became one of his staples. She does not look a day over 30.
Also according to the narrative provided by Christie’s, the work has had multiple residences and did some international traveling in its 105 years of existence. She was with her creator for 33 years until 1954 (Estate of the artist), and then passed to his daughter, Marguerite Matisse-Duthuit (1894-1982) as inheritance. While Marguerite worked to document Matisse’s legacy, the Nude did some modest sightseeing in Europe. Marguerite sold this painting in January 1965 to two New York galleries, M. Knoedler & Co., Inc., New York, and Perls Galleries (joint owners) who then sold it to the Kimbell Art Foundation/Museum in Fort Worth, Texas, three and a half years later (16 September 1968). [Naturally, both Knoedler and Perls Galleries have made art law precedent and left marks in law books as a warning to collectors, dealers and experts to learn from.]
Catalogue de l’oeuvre

There is no single catalogue raisonné for Matisse. He was a prolific artist and there are a fair number of publications about his drawings and collages. In 2025, François Blondel and Hélène Ivanoff produced Catalogue de l’oeuvre peint de Henri Matisse (Blondel/Ivanoff). According to the Blondel/Ivanoff catalogue the Nude (collection particulière) dates to 1922 (see Nus 1922, gr. 28.3, p. 413) while a series of studies for it was done in 1921. Does the exact date of execution matter? It depends. Apparently the work is not dated on the canvas or the stretchers. After all, Christie’s does not warrant the date of the work, just its attribution.
Blondel/Ivanoff explain that Knoedler/Frank Perls bought the work jointly from Marguerite Duthuit for 102,129 USD (see p. 413).
Table of Contents (the “Table”) of the Blondel/Ivanoff catalogue is worth reading for its form and style. It shows that the 624-page opus is divided into lists, indexes and art organized in three parts, with chronological sections 1869-1917 (l’innovateur [the innovator]), 1918-1934, (couleurs et harmonies, corps et décors [color and harmonies, bodies and interiors]), and 1935-1954 (l’inspiration revenue [inspiration regained]).
Each chronological section loosely maps the artist’s life against locations where he lived or visited during the corresponding periods. Part I, section 3.4, for example, includes cities he visited in 1911 in France and abroad (see what I did there), Part II mentions Nice multiple times by name, and sets apart work for Barnes in Merion, but nothing about his visit in New York City where his son, an art dealer, had been living since 1924, nothing about being on the jury for the Carnegie International exhibition in Pittsburgh in 1930, or trips to San Francisco and Baltimore.
The catalogue is a tour de force of provenance research. Its references to the Einsatzstab Reichsleiter Rosenberg (ERR) and Musées Nationaux Récupération (MNR) point to the histories of other Matisse works and, in some cases, their restitution.
For some reason, probably copyright law, while the Blondel/Ivanoff Catalogue is offered for sale by Pallant House Gallery Bookshop (the trading name of Gallery Bookshop Ltd.) it is “not available to purchase for customers in the USA.” It is available for shipment to Switzerland, Ukraine and Russia.
Flipping through the entries for the 1,413 works in the catalogue is instructive and distractive. Some works are represented by blank rectangles (reproduction not available) or snippets of receipts, other reproductions are grayed out because no color image is available or because their current whereabouts are unknown, and, whether missing for now or lost forever, some works were never photographed in color. Following any one work in particular becomes a detour of a few minutes or longer. Here is one, Le Marche d’onion (1918) (19.018, p. 290), owned by Gaston Prosper Lévy (1893-1977), co-founder of what became the Monoprix supermarket chain in France. Black and white reproduction. His collection was looted during the Nazi occupation and, while Lévy survived miraculously by fleeing to Tunisia, the painting went missing. Skimming through the catalogue, the reader is reminded that some works were never recovered and others popped up in the Gurlitt trove. Perhaps the new tools for provenance research, able to sift through mountains of archives, will help trace where these works went and whose hands they passed through, as soon as 2027. Back to the present.
Nice is nice

In 1917, Henri Matisse moved to the Côte d’Azur and soon made Nice and the towns nearby his playground/home. After his death, a villa near the Excelsior-Régina Palace Hotel in Cimiez, in the hills overlooking Nice, was set up to house his collection. In 2026, the Musée Matisse presented a two-artist show, Alex Katz (b. 1927) and Matisse (b. 1869 – d. 1954), side by side: dancing figures, landscapes, natures mortes. All in all, a delightful show set in a lovely jewel box of a museum, surrounded by olive trees, on the hills overlooking Nice and descending to the Mediterranean that inspired so many and attracted so much (capital and all). Museum wall text proclaims that Katz was born to “Russian parents.” What a jarring surprise that must have been for the parents. In fact, his parents were Jewish immigrants from the Odesa region, Isaac and Sima Katz (her stage name Ella Marion), but why would that matter in 2026, as the Russian army keeps destroying not only the Odesa port and old city but all of Ukraine?! Lack of docents at the museum saved them from a tirade by an irate visitor.
Matisse’s main model in 1921/1922 was Henriette Darricarrère; he painted her dozens if not hundreds of times, sitting, reclining. She is the one reclining in the 1922 painting. In 2018, his Odalisque couchée aux magnolias (1923), likely painted also from Henriette, sold through Christie’s spring sale for $80.75 million, setting the public sale record for Matisse. Its provenance included Sam Salz, a renowned art dealer born in Galicia, who sold it to David and Peggy Rockfeller in 1958.
Everybody knows, recognizes and loves Matisse, one of the Fauves. Matisse traveled a fair amount, visiting Tahiti, Morocco and Spain, as well as the Russian Empire and the United States. His ties to Russian collectors and culture include his trip to Moscow in 1911 at the invitation of the famous Sergei Shchukin (Russian businessman and art collector). Shchukin’s collection, including Matisse’s La Danse and other canvases, was nationalized after the 1917 Revolution. Subsequently, irreconcilable differences and the need for cultural exchanges between east and west led to the passing of numerous immunity-from-seizure laws. His ties to American collectors were strong during his lifetime and posthumously.
Matisse’s affiliation with the United States is stronger, if only judging by the fact that he visited there multiple times in the 1930s. Also, his son Pierre opened a gallery in New York City, where he was selling his father’s and others’ works. During the painter’s trips to the US, Matisse was invited by another collector, Albert C. Barnes, to Pennsylvania to paint for the Barnes Foundation gallery building. For him, Matisse painted a mural called The Dance, cousin of Shchukin’s La Danse. The Barnes Collection too has had a legal chapter as part of its history, the story of trusts and estates, the dead hand grasping and losing grasp of a priceless collection. While Shchukin’s Dance was nationalized, Barnes’ Dance was relocated under deviation doctrine from Merion to Philadelphia. Wishes of both collectors were ultimately disregarded. So much law swirling around art (authenticity, restitution, money laundering, resale royalty rights), as a warning sign for those willing to take in signs.
Apparently, 1992 was a rollercoaster year for Matisse works. In 1992, the Kimbell Art Museum must have deaccessioned Nu au châle vert, because by November 1992 it was already in a private collection in Palm Beach, Florida (not quite the Côte d’Azur, but also a sunny and glamorous seaside). In 1993 the Kimbell Art Museum accessioned a later Matisse, L’Asie/Asia (1946) that was auctioned in November of 1992 by Sotheby’s New York and bought by Kimbell Art Museum for $11 million, with the assistance of Acquavella Galleries. Whether the Nude was deaccessioned to fund acquisition of Asia may be the subject of another expose. Suffice it to say that Kimbell Art Museum, like other members of the American Alliance of Museums, was subject to the museum standards and codes of ethics and could only deaccession art for purposes of new acquisitions or direct care of collections.
Writing for The Washington Post, in 1992 Judd Tully observed the number of highs and lows:
“As anticipated, Henri Matisse’s “Asia” dominated the evening, fetching a buoyant $11.1 million. It was purchased by the renowned New York art dealer, William Acquavella, acting as agent for the Kimbell Art Foundation of Fort Worth. The foundation is the owner and operator of the well-endowed museum.
While the Matisse missed the artist’s record of $12.3 million set in October 1989, it nevertheless became the highest price for a modern picture since the downturn. …
Back on the Matisse trail, “The Red Beach” (1905) realized 1.25 million to $1.75 million estimate). It belonged to the collection of the late Wright S. Ludington, the founder and major patron of the Santa Barbara (Calif.) Museum of Art.
“The Pink Shrimps” (1920) was “bought in” at $1.6 million when it failed to meet its secret reserve price. Estimated to bring from $2.5 million to $3.5 million, this Matisse was deaccessioned by the Everhart Museum in Scranton, Pa., following court-won permission to sell the work. It was much ado about nothing.
Outside of the MOMA trio, five other Matisses were offered, including “The Dancer,” a painted paper cutout from 1949 that sold for $341,000 to Zurich dealer Thomas Ammann, who left the salesroom with his escort, Bianca Jagger. It comes from the estate of the painter Robert Motherwell. Of the eight Matisses offered, five failed to sell.”
What happened to 1921/1922 Nu (a.k.a. Lot 33A) between 1992 and 2011 is unclear. Somehow, she went back on the road (or is it taken by water, or air?), because, as is stated in the Christie’s description, by 2011 she was back in Europe, in another private collection (the name of which is conspicuously omitted from the lot description and Blondel/Ivanoff). If the Catalogue of Blondel were a digital tool, by November 18, 2026, some of the pieces listed in it would already show updated exhibition and sale information.
The Oligarch
The penultimate line in the provenance section of Lot 33A reads “Private collection, Europe (by 2011).” Rather opaque, on a need-to-know basis perhaps, and that is where the public records of court filings become handy.
According to the Federal Court complaint filed in 2018, this very Matisse odalisque, Nu au châle vert, was bought by Dmitry Rybolovlev, the Russian “potash king,” in 2011 from an undisclosed seller, with a valuation provided by Sotheby’s, through the Swiss dealer Yves Bouvier. The bond forged and then broken between the oligarch and his art dealer, now the subject of the three-part documentary The Oligarch and the Art Dealer (2026), set off a slew of lawsuits around the world and kept countless attorneys and paralegals busy. For the US federal case alone, closed by October 23, 2024, the docket is 726 entries (billable pages to see the docket alone cost $3, never mind the individual letters to the judge, copious motions, numerous exhibits, etc.). You would have to be an oligarch to read the court proceedings from start to end.
Dmitry Rybolovlev was the same oligarch who in 2008 bought Maison de l’Amitié in Palm Beach from Donald Trump for a reported $95 million. An owner of expensive real estate and yachts, in short succession, he purchased nearly 40 works of art from the Swiss art dealer Yves Bouvier, including the record-setting Salvator Mundi, which was sold with great fanfare through Christie’s in 2017 for $450 million+.

According to the 2023 Opinion and Order by Judge Jesse M. Furman delivered five years later in Accent Delight v. Sotheby’s, the case brought by Rybolovlev in connection with the Matisse and other works sold to him by Bouvier (ruling in the spring of 2023), Matisse’s Nude was sold to Rybolovlev in 2011 for $85 million plus about a 2% commission. The decision states that “As part of his art business, Bouvier operated through two distinct entities, Blancaflor Investments Ltd. (“Blancaflor”) and Mei Invest Ltd. (“Mei”), and worked with Peretti to source deals.” As part of managing his funds, Rybolovlev was connected as the ultimate beneficial owner to two companies operating out of the British Virgin Islands, Accent Delight International Ltd. and Xitrans Finance Ltd. We have all been trying to put two and two together and the math has not been simple.

The docket entry 468-183, which corresponds to just one Exhibit, no. 176 of 28 pages, in case 1:2018cv09011, reveals that the work’s insurance value in 2014 was listed at $85 million.
In 2015, Rybolovlev filed a criminal complaint in Monaco and sought to freeze Bouvier’s assets in Singapore in connection with the art Bouvier sold him. Alleged wrongs: breach of fiduciary duty and fraud. Also in 2015, Rybolovlev sold the Matisse.
With the penultimate line of provenance apparently deciphered with help of court filings, let’s move to the last line “Acquired from the above by the present owner, November 2015.” The present owner must be the “Distinguished American collector” who consigned this work for sale in 2026. Who might that be? Putting two and two together again, after the “present owner” bought the Nude, he (we think it is a he) imported her back to the US and lent her to Portland to hang in 2017.
Christie’s account of Lot 33A’s publication, exhibition and ownership histories makes no reference to 2022, the centennial of the painting’s creation according to some and the start of the full scale invasion of Ukraine to so many of us. According to Blondel/Ivanoff entry on page 413, in 2022 the Nude was back in France ‘en vent’/ for sale and probably on display at Paris+ par Art Basel with Acquavella Galleries. Apparently, not only the market was under the weather that fall. The Nude did not sell in 2022 and the detour was not worth mentioning in 2026 sales marketing materials.
Real Gossip: Who is “Distinguished American Collector”?
Born in 1942, Steven A. Wynn has been a real-estate developer and collector for a long time. In 2005, he opened Wynn Fine Art, with offices in Nevada (Las Vegas), Florida (Palm Beach), New York (NYC) and California (Beverly Hills). Incidentally, he has over 158K followers on Instagram…
Is it possible that Wynn purchased this painting from Rybolovlev in 2015, when the Rybolovlev-Bouvier legal battle was underway? Wynn Fine Art offers a brief description of a Matisse painting “ (1921/1922) Nu au Chale Vert, same size as Lot 33A but with no illustration.
Is it a stretch to say paintings have types (of collectors)? If our reading of the facts and sources is correct, both Rybolovlev and Wynn have bought this painting for their collections because they could. They share more than collecting proclivities, they have similar taste in real estate and climates. Wynn is known to have been granted honorary Monegasque citizenship in 2010, the year Rybolovlev relocated to Monaco. In 2012, both purchased apartments in Manhattan, reportedly overlooking Central Park, reportedly with the assistance of agents from Brown Harris Stevens. Just two billionaires making their homes on or around the Billionaires’ Row.
Whoever acquired the Matisse in 2015, Rybolovlev’s later designation as a sanctioned person by Ukrainian Presidential Decree, for ten years from 19 October 2022, had no bearing on the present-day status and ownership of the painting. The fact that Rybolovlev’s name was not included in the provenance in Christie’s catalogue description violates no legal prescriptions. Is the omission irrelevant to the full picture of the current state of the world and the art market? This author has her opinion but no explanation for either the auction results or the outcome of the war in Ukraine.
We each choose our path: some follow the money, others follow the art. Sanctions regimes are foreign-policy tools that seek to change the course of those who have access to both, and who are deemed directly involved in, benefiting from, or otherwise complicit in conduct that governments seek to deter. Beyond the law lie ethics and morality. What they demand is for each of us to weigh, and for all of us to tell these stories as fully and truthfully as we can.
The Nude has been seen and admired since the start: in France, with Galerie Bernheim-Jeune et Cie, and then in Venice for two Biennales, first in 1928 (by then, the national pavilion built for the Russian Empire, with financing provided by the Ukrainian collector Bohdan Khanenko, was already showing Soviet artists) and again in the year Matisse died. Then the Nude crossed the ocean to be seen in LA in 1966 (soon after the US passed immunity from seizure for temporarily imported works of art on loan; just a coincidence of overlapping timelines). She lay low for nearly 30 years, with no recorded public show until 2017, when she came on loan to the Portland Art Museum. Fast forward nearly a decade: most recently, surrounded by other magnificent Matisse works at Acquavella Galleries on the Upper East Side (18 E 79th Street) in the show Matisse: The Pursuit of Harmony (April–May 2026), the line of people queuing to see the celebration of light and line stretched toward Central Park all the way to the Ukrainian Institute of America at 2 E 79th Street. Who knew so many people were interested in the Pursuit of Harmony?!
Just ahead of the November auctions, Realtor.com reported that Wynn finally sold his Central Park condo for $70 million. It was apparently put up for sale in 2022 (history does not end or start on a certain date but dates do resonate), and had to drop the asking price before offloading the Ritz-Carlton Residences (Formerly Hotel St. Moritz) onto the next lucky guy. Apparently “casino magnate failed to turn a profit on the 10,875-square-foot condo. But given that, according to Forbes, Wynn is worth $4.3 billion, he likely isn’t sweating it too much.” Unless Rybolovlev sold the work to someone else and that transaction went unlisted, it is possible that in 2015 it was Wynn who purchased the Nude from Rybolovlev, and his was the distinguished American collection that consigned it to Christie’s.
Whoever is bidding on blue chip art this season, it is their prerogative. Whether they choose to use money for philanthropy or peacemaking is also up to them. He who pays the piper calls the tune. The piper has the choice not to accept the money.
How long shall we dance around it?
Like Janus, the world, with its synchronicities and niceties, is two-faced: exhilarating and exhausting, beguiling and unattractive. We seem to be dancing around issues and having a jolly time about it. The art market is a dazzling circus of eye candy and eyebrows. Look at the wares, look at the characters! Who are the bedfellows, and does it matter? Let them eat cake! What values does it have and present? Legally? Morally? Ethically? What matters at the end of the day? Season? Sale? That the sun comes up the next day and we have a chance to do things over, and do them better.
As for Matisse, before becoming an artist, he was a student of law. For the longest time he painted nature morte, before focusing on a female figure. At the Musée Matisse in Nice, the very first work by the artist is called Nature mortes aux livres (1890), signed ‘essitaM.’ It shows a stack of books, perhaps law treatises. A point of departure. Would he have given up on law had there been art law in his time? Would he have given up on art, had he known his works would be used as stalking horses? It is unimportant because what could have been does not matter. All that matters is what was, what is, and …

Lot 33A was hammered down at the low estimate – $18,000,000 – in under two minutes, to a bidder on the phone with Conor Jordan, Deputy Chairman, Impressionist & Modern Art, Americas. Price realised: $21,380 million. Whoever the next owner of Lot 33A (a.k.a. paddle 2761, a.k.a. Conor Jordan’s telephone) is they will face familiar choices, and so will whoever sells it next. Will they lend Nu au châle vert to a museum or put her in storage? Will they make their name public or remain just another “private collection”? If and when they sell her, which previous owners will they allow to be revealed, and so on, until the next act of this painting’s life. There is nothing wrong with liking, loving or owning a Matisse, this odalisque or watching the spectacle as it unfolds. There is something wrong with the numbers of the present. The present is so well funded that it keeps dealing blow after blow to our exposed solar plexus.
About the Author:
Irina Tarsis, founder of the Center for Art Law, is an art historian and attorney. The author thanks the Center for Art Law team for their feedback, as well as the journalists, art historians and developers working to bring transparency and clarity to the (art) world.
Select Sources:
Henri Matisse, Nu au châle vert (Nu couché, bras gauche replié) (1921), Lot 33A, Christie’s: 20th Century Evening Sale, Live Auction 24266 (Nov. 17, 2026), https://www.christies.com/en/lot/lot-6614754.
François Blondel & Hélène Ivanoff, Catalogue de l’œuvre peint de Henri Matisse: 1869–1954, 413 (2025).
Der Oligarch und der Kunsthändler [The Oligarch and the Art Dealer] (Arte 2026), https://www.arte.tv/de/videos/116313-002-A/der-oligarch-und-der-kunsthaendler-2-3/.
Nude with a Green Shawl, Henri Matisse, Sanctions.Art, https://sanctions.art/artworks/62173b25-b529-453c-9451-568e019971bc (last visited Nov. 18, 2026).
Accent Delight Int’l Ltd. v. Sotheby’s, No. 18-cv-9011 (JMF) (S.D.N.Y. Mar. 1, 2023) (opinion and order).
Exhibit 176, Accent Delight Int’l Ltd. v. Sotheby’s, No. 18-cv-9011 (JMF) (S.D.N.Y.), ECF No. 468-183.
Judd Tully, “A Stinging Blow to Art Market Expectations”, Wash. Post, Nov. 11, 1992, https://juddtully.net/auctions/a-stinging-blow-to-art-market-expectations/ .
Kiri Blakeley, Casino Mogul Steve Wynn Sells His $70 Million Central Park Condo as Manhattan Luxury Market Heats Up, Realtor.com (Nov. 9, 2026), https://www.realtor.com/news/trends/steve-wynn-sells-central-park-condo-ritz-carlton/.
Artnet and Kalshi Partner on Art Industry Prediction Markets, Artnet News (Nov. 11, 2026), https://news.artnet.com/market/artnet-kalshi-partner-art-prediction-markets-2832366.
Nu au Chale Vert (1921 – 1922), Wynn Fine Art, https://wynnfineart.com/artists/nu-au-chale-vert-1921-1922/ (last visited Nov. 18, 2026).
Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and is not meant to provide legal advice. Readers should not construe or rely on any comment or statement in this article as legal advice. For legal advice, readers should seek a consultation with an attorney.
You must be logged in to post a comment.