By Murphy Yanbing Chen
Introduction—Copyright and Creative Commons Licensing
Where does creativity come from? Like the legal principle of stare decisis, many artistic creations do not exist in a vacuum. Artists often look at and borrow from prior masters or their peers for inspiration. However, not all “visual borrowing” complies with copyright laws or licensing agreements. Copyright infringement, for example, is the direct result of using a protected work without seeking the author’s permission.[1] As digital technology progresses, more cases of sharing or borrowing unauthorized, copyrighted visual content are unchecked. While legislation fell behind in playing catchup with technology, alternative legal measurements such as Creative Commons (“CC”) licenses started filling the gap in the law.
Copyright laws and licensing agreements establish rights and restrictions for authors and users to own, use, and remix digitized content. However, they take different approaches to implement their legal effect. On the one hand, Copyright follows an “all rights reserved” approach.[2] All the rights under the U.S. Copyright Law —moral and economic rights to reproduce, distribute, publicly perform, display, and make derivatives—belong to the authors. Copyright excludes others other than the authors from utilizing the protected contents as statutory protection endures. On the other hand, licensing agreements follow the “some rights reserved” approach.[3] For example, CC licenses recognize all copyrights for the authors, yet they “address them in a way that grants re-users the right to use licensed materials according to the license terms as far as national law permits.”[4]