By Filip Radzikowski
Fractionalized ownership is not a novel idea. The legal, financial and social ramifications of this investment scheme were extensively analyzed in various fields, including the art market. However, only recently has it experienced an exceptional surge in popularity in Asia and the Middle East[1] and recently it is getting footing in European and US markets. Fractional ownership gained popularity in the mid-80’s and was originally employed in the context of business jets, later migrating to real estate. The early 2010s welcomed this form of investment with open arms in the fine arts, with numerous newly established companies drawing on the contemporary art market returns exceeding the S&P 500 in the same timeframe.[2] The significance of fractional ownership lies in the variety of modes it can take, seemingly disrupting traditional forms of investment. A prior article written by the Center for Art Law on the share-buying in LLCs’, most notably offered by Masterwork, should provide our readers a valuable insight into legal considerations of a more traditional fractionalization scheme. Nevertheless, the digital realm attracts an increasing number of players in the fractionalized art investment market. The advent of blockchain technology and the tokenization process has disrupted the markets, including for fine arts. Undoubtedly, these present revolutionary solutions to investors. On the other hand, their vulnerabilities are already viewed as exploitable for illicit financial operations, of which both the Department of the Treasury[3] and Financial Action Task Force (FATF) are cautious in their recent (2023) Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and Countering the Financing of Terrorism (CFT) studies.[4]
Art investment, and blue-chip art in particular, usually require onerous financial backing, which for many interested in capitalising on the art market, constitutes an unattainable threshold.[5] Therefore, fractional art ownership is a rapidly expanding field and a “natural outgrowth of the financialization of the art market.”[6] Making headlines, companies like Particle Collection or recently launched Freeport had seen fractionalizing tokenized art as a growing investment opportunity, digitising the ownership claims and dividing works of Banksy or Andy Warhol. Artemundi, a US-based art investment company with over 30-year’s worth of experience, in partnership with Swiss bank Sygnum had notably bought Picasso’s Fillette au beret painting to be fractionalized into 4000 pieces of the Art Security Tokens (AST)[7]; another joint undertaking between Rubey and Tokeny had the same idea for introducing the tokenized claims to custodied assets, while the painting (Carnaval de Binche by James Ensor) is being loaned long-term to the Royal Museum of Fine Arts in Antwerp.[8] Tokeny also partnered with Artory on bringing permissioned tokens under code-name T-rex to increase transparency and compliance with the current AML regime.[9] Considering AML rules as a jurisdiction bound regime, the digital sphere transcends these boundaries which makes fractionalized art especially complex subject to regulation, especially as there is no uniformity in the digitization process.